tcpip: (Default)
[personal profile] tcpip
On Thursday I gave my paper at AUUG on the Econmics of Open Source; I only have a handful of slides, with further notes forthcoming, but even that should be enough to illustrate the main point - that software patents and copyright are a form of monopoly that are ultimately anti-competitive, despite driving research and development in the first instance. My conclusion (with an explicit "this must be developed further") recommended public and financial incentives that do not rely on patents and copyrights.

In addition to giving the paper I also found myself chairing a session with an excellent paper on the new Falcon storage engine for MySQL by none other than [livejournal.com profile] arjen_lentz, Nikolai Lusan's paper on LDAP and the "one password per user" objective (users are dangerous to themselves, imo), and Rob Pike's illustrative "Fault Tolerance At Google" (go on, guess what google's infrastructure runs on). Other presentations I attended included "Open Documentation Framework" by Michael Strong, Jonathan Oxer's "Software Freedom: Pragmatic Idealism?" (which, with a bit of work could become a showcase paper on why educators should teach Linux) and Paul McGowan's paper on vehicular recording devices for car insurance etc (which I have started to promote to certain other individuals as a viable business proposition). On the Friday, after attending their AGM, I decided to join AUUG.

On Saturday I attended the biennial Pax Christi conference. I was expecting a bunch of Christian hippies; they were - except they were hippies from the sixties. I swear I was one of the youngest people in attendance and I ain't that young. That said, the presentations were excellent. Associate Professor Richard Chauvel gave a great overview of the democratic transformation and decentralisation of Indonesia and what this means for regional independence movements, and barristers John Rutherford and Brian Walters gave detailed summaries of the extraordinary scope of Australia's anti-terrorist laws. A moot point was whether AWB executives could be charged with terrorism for siphoning money off to Saddam Hussein's regime.

If there was a negative, it was the final session on peace in the middle east which included Sam Haddad (Lebanese Christian view), John Cohen (Jewish perspective) and Issam Nabulsi (Muslim perspective). All seemed to assume that their point of view was the correct one; none addressed the possibility of secular democracy with universal rights. Cohen was particularly belligerent, the quietly spoken Nabulsi argued for a "true" Islamic state and Haddad suggested that Lebanon was attacked by Israel because they have the best chance of competing against that State. It is little wonder that Prof. Joe Camilleri said in summing up "Perhaps we ought to ask whether religion is the solution or the problem in the Middle East".

Also convened an executive meeting of Prosper Australia on Thursday and attended their housing and homelessness forum on Friday. Ken Fernandes gave an excellent overview of the situation in South East Asia and the Indian sub-continient where he has done most of his work as part of the Asian Coalition for Housing Rights. Also last Sunday week gave my paper on "The Age of Spiritual Machines" (not online yet) which was very well received; I think Kurzweil has made a basic mathematical error in his book however. Some gaming has occurred as well, natch; finished module U3 in our Norman Britian game, generated some characters for the "Aesheba", Greek Africa Everyway game, saved people from pirates (arrgh!) in DragonQuest and finished the Crystal Palace orbital Cybernoia scenario.

Date: 2006-10-16 04:09 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] zey.livejournal.com
"The requested URL /auug2006.pdf was not found on this server."

Just generally though, I don't know of any software developers who think software patents are a good idea. Copyright's enough to protect a work, patents are just insane. Huge boos to John Howard for exposing us to this horror by signing off on the Aus/US FTA.

Date: 2006-10-16 04:18 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] tcpip.livejournal.com

Whoops. Upside down miss jane. auug_2006.pdf

Date: 2006-10-16 05:00 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] strangedave.livejournal.com
Hate to say it, but it sounds like your 'economics of open source' paper correctly identified well known problems, and then ducked out on suggesting solutions to the problems everyone is trying to find solutions for. Still, its a bit harsh to expect you to find solutions to problems that the entire world is grappling with.

Was the google paper about their google file system, or other stuff?

The real tragedy of Lebanon was an emerging state with an emerging tolerant pluralist vibrant culture (at least in Beirut) that has probably been bombed back into militancy.

I'd be interested to read your thoughts on Kurzweil - I have great distrust of the utopian maths of the singularitarians.

Date: 2006-10-16 05:08 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] tcpip.livejournal.com

Your criticism that it ducked out at the end is sort of correct; I wanted to give the audience (who were largely not economics literate) an overview of the issues - including the advantages of patents and copyrights in the lexicon of economics.

There are plans for Prosper and AUUG or similar to co-sponsor a conference next year which will deal more comprehensively with the issues.

Google paper was on the redundant systems (software and hardware). They go cheap and assume breakage.

I have great distrust of the utopian maths of the singularitarians.

It is more descriptive than anything else and I note that Kurzweil is always careful enough to differentiate between "thinking" and "computing capacity". Doesn't stop him from being out by a factor of two however in predicting that capacity.


Profile

tcpip: (Default)
Diary of a B+ Grade Polymath

May 2025

S M T W T F S
    123
4 5678910
1112131415 1617
18192021 222324
2526 272829 3031

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jun. 3rd, 2025 02:41 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios